MORAL STORIES

Bullies mocked her by shaving her police dog, never realizing her father is a Delta Force commander.


MAX

John Carter did not notice the tattoo at first.

At first, all he saw was blood.

It ran in thin, uneven lines down Max’s side, dark against pale skin that had never been meant to see the sun. Twelve years of thick German Shepherd fur had hidden that skin from the world, had protected it from heat, eyes, and cruelty. Now it lay exposed beneath the brutal Texas sky, shaved raw, sliced carelessly, still wet where the razor had bitten too deep.

John dropped to his knees without thinking. His jacket came off in one sharp movement, hands already shaking as he wrapped it around Max’s body. The fabric barely covered him. It wasn’t enough, but John pressed it close anyway, as if pressure alone could undo what had been done.

Max trembled.

Not from fear. Not even from pain.

From shock.

Emily was crying beside him, the kind of crying that made no sound at first, just air dragging in and out of her chest like it hurt to breathe. Rope burns circled her wrists, red and swollen, skin broken where she had fought to pull free. Her backpack lay several feet away in the dirt, spilled open like a body that had been searched.

Down the road, laughter echoed.

Young voices. Careless. Fading.

John didn’t look up.

He was staring at Max’s side.

Because beneath the blood and the uneven shave, something darker showed through.

Ink.

Faded, scarred, old.

He wiped at the skin with his sleeve, gently, carefully, afraid of what he might see and more afraid of what he already suspected. As the blood smeared away, the shape became clear.

Numbers.

Not random.

Not decorative.

Burned deep into flesh the way military ink always was.

K94721.

John stopped breathing.

For a moment, the world narrowed to those six characters. His heart hammered hard enough that he felt dizzy. He knew those numbers. Not the exact sequence, but the format. The weight of it. The way it sat on skin like ownership.

Joint Special Operations Command.

The kind of marking that did not end up on family dogs. The kind that did not belong to strays or shelter rescues or forgotten animals.

The kind that meant service.

The kind that meant secrecy.

The kind that meant Max was not who John had thought he was.

Nearby, half buried in dust, lay a metal tag John had never seen before. It was scratched, dulled with age, but unmistakably military. He picked it up, turned it over, and felt something inside him give way.

Max wasn’t just old.

Max was a ghost.

That morning had started the way most mornings did.

Quiet.

Scrambled eggs hissed softly in the skillet, edges browning a little too much because John’s attention drifted sometimes. The kitchen smelled of cheap coffee and hot oil, of routines worn smooth by repetition. He scraped the pan clean and divided the last of the shredded cheese between Emily’s plate and Max’s bowl without comment.

Sunlight slipped through the window in narrow bands, catching dust motes that drifted lazily in the air. Max sat beside Emily’s chair, his graying muzzle resting against her knee. He did not beg. He never had. He simply waited, patient as gravity.

Twelve years old.

His hips bothered him now, especially when the weather changed. Cold mornings made him slow. His once-black fur had silvered around the eyes and mouth, giving him a permanent look of quiet thoughtfulness. But his eyes themselves—dark, steady, watchful—had not changed.

Emily slipped him a piece of bacon when she thought John wasn’t looking.

John pretended not to notice.

Some rules weren’t worth the cost.

An envelope waited on the counter, white and sharp against the dull laminate. The vet bill. Three hundred and forty dollars. Past due, stamped in red that felt louder than it needed to be.

John didn’t open it again. He already knew the numbers.

His VA check barely covered rent and groceries. The truck hadn’t run in months, transmission shot beyond anything he could afford. Walking was their reality now. A mile here, a mile there. Pain learned to behave when you didn’t give it attention.

“Ready?” he asked.

Emily nodded, backpack slung over one shoulder. She was ten now, old enough to insist she didn’t need help, but she reached for his hand anyway when they stepped onto the porch.

The heat hit them immediately. Texas did not believe in gentle seasons. September still burned like summer, the sun already heavy even this early.

Max followed them down the steps, nails clicking softly, moving with the careful dignity of age.

The walk to town was just over a mile. John counted steps when his leg began to ache, the old injury from Helmand Province reminding him it still existed. Emily filled the space with stories about school, about Mrs. Chen’s new puppy, about nothing and everything.

John listened like it mattered.

Because it did.

Halfway down Oakwood Road, Max slowed.

Not much. Just enough.

His ears lifted. His nose tilted into the air.

John felt it immediately, the way you feel pressure change before a storm.

“Keep walking,” he murmured, his hand settling on Emily’s shoulder.

The pharmacy was quick. Mrs. Rosa counted exact change, then added a bottle of Advil without saying a word. Emily asked about dog treats. John said no. She nodded, already learning restraint in places children shouldn’t have to.

They took the shortcut home through the park.

Rusty swings creaked in the breeze. Cicadas buzzed thick in the trees. The sound wrapped around them, almost soothing.

Then engines broke the rhythm.

Max followed them out of the pharmacy with the same careful dignity he carried everywhere now, nails clicking softly on the sidewalk as if he were apologizing for the sound. John kept Emily close, hand light on her shoulder, eyes scanning the street the way he used to scan ridgelines. He told himself it was habit. He told himself it was nothing. But the feeling that Max had caught on the wind didn’t leave. It stayed, a pressure behind the ribs, a quiet certainty that the world was about to turn its face toward them.

They took the park shortcut because John’s leg was already complaining, a deep ache that sharpened with every step. The park hadn’t changed since Emily was little—still the same rusted swings and cracked basketball court, still the same bleached benches with names carved into them, still the same lazy creek at the edge of the grass where kids sometimes tossed stones and pretended they were brave enough to wade in. Cicadas buzzed loud enough to make the air feel thick. For a moment, John let himself imagine that this was all it was: a walk home, a dog with old hips, a daughter talking too fast about school because she didn’t know how else to keep the world stable.

Then the engines came.

Three trucks rolled in like they owned the road, lifted high, chrome gleaming, tires wide and clean as if they’d never seen mud. They weren’t heading somewhere. They were arriving. The sound of them swallowed the cicadas in an instant, and the park felt smaller.

Max moved before John did.

He stepped in front of Emily, body angled between her and the trucks, tail low, ears forward, posture steady. Not panicked. Not aggressive. Just a dog doing the single thing he had always done: placing himself where he needed to be.

Six young men climbed out, all confidence and careless laughter. Early twenties. Sunglasses too expensive. Shoes too white. Faces that had never been forced to learn humility. The leader wore his entitlement the way other men wore uniforms.

John recognized him the same way you recognize a storm cloud on a clear horizon.

Cody Brennan. Sheriff’s son.

“Just passing through,” John said, keeping his voice level. Not pleading, not challenging. A simple fact offered to a world that should have accepted it.

Cody didn’t look at John at first. He looked at Max. His mouth twisted like he’d found something funny.

“That’s an ugly dog,” he said.

Max’s chest rumbled, low and controlled, a warning more felt than heard. John’s hand settled on Max’s head, fingers pressing into fur, steadying the dog and steadying himself. Emily’s breath caught. John felt it in the way her shoulder tensed under his palm.

“We don’t want trouble,” John said.

Someone laughed. Someone else pulled out a phone.

“Yo,” a voice said, already excited, “this is gonna go viral.”

John guided Emily to the side, making space the way you do when you pass through someone else’s bad day and don’t want to inherit it. Max limped but stayed between the men and the girl, gait stiff but purpose unwavering. Cody stepped sideways to keep pace, like a predator playing with distance.

Emily looked down at her shoes. Shame burns quietly, and children absorb it fast.

John didn’t look back.

Behind them, engines revved.

And then the trucks began to follow at a crawl, slow enough to say: we’re still here, we’re watching, we can.

John kept walking because he’d learned a long time ago that some fights weren’t won by striking first. But even as he walked, he stored details—license plates, faces, the angle of Cody’s grin. He stored them the way he used to store grid coordinates. He didn’t want violence. He didn’t want trouble. But he refused to be helpless.

When they finally turned onto Oakwood Road again and the trucks peeled away, the silence felt wrong. Emily didn’t speak for most of the walk. Max kept glancing back, ears swiveling, reading the world.

At the house, John locked the door behind them out of instinct, even though he hated that he did. Emily went to her room, backpack thumping against the wall as she dropped it, a small angry sound. Max stood in the kitchen doorway, watching John.

John knelt and looked into the dog’s eyes.

“It’s okay,” he murmured, though he didn’t know if it was. Max’s gaze held steady, as if he were listening not to the words but to the truth beneath them. Then he turned, slow, and padded toward Emily’s room, placing himself where the fear was.

That afternoon, John called the vet.

Not because he could afford it, but because Max’s skin had been itching more than usual, and there was a smell under the fur that made John think of infection. He left a message. He checked the bills again. He did the math again. The math didn’t care about dignity.

By evening, Emily came out quiet, face washed, eyes puffy.

“Dad,” she said, hovering in the doorway, “those boys… they were laughing at Max.”

John kept his voice gentle. “Some people laugh because they don’t know what else to do with their emptiness.”

Emily didn’t fully understand, but she nodded anyway, taking comfort in the steadiness of his tone. Max pressed his head against her hip and she rested her hand on his neck, fingers threading into fur.

That night, John slept lightly.

At some point, he woke to Max standing at the foot of his bed, ears tilted, body still. Not asking to go out. Not restless. Just alert.

John sat up slowly.

“What is it?” he whispered.

Max didn’t move, but his eyes tracked toward the window.

John got up, limping slightly, and peered through the blinds.

Nothing.

Just the street, a pool of lamplight, an empty road.

But the feeling didn’t leave.

The next day began like it always did—coffee, eggs, Emily’s hair a mess, Max waiting patiently as if he still believed the world had order. John walked Emily toward school, and Max came with them as far as the corner, sitting until they were out of sight, the way he always did. When John turned back, he found himself looking around again, scanning cars, watching porches, noticing which curtains shifted.

By noon, John’s phone buzzed with a notification he hadn’t expected.

A neighbor’s text, short, blunt: “You need to see what Cody posted.”

John didn’t have social media. He had never wanted it. But the neighbor sent a link anyway. John stared at it for a long moment before tapping. The video loaded slowly. The thumbnail showed Max—Max’s face—close to the camera, confused, eyes wide.

John’s stomach dropped.

He watched.

He watched his dog on the ground, restrained, his fur being shaved in jagged strips, hands yanking, laughter filling the audio like poison. He watched someone drag Emily by the arms, her screams breaking, her wrists pulled tight with rope. He watched Max try to rise, try to place himself between them, and fail because he was old and his body had limits. He watched Cody lean into the frame, grinning, saying something that made the others laugh harder.

John didn’t remember setting the phone down. He only remembered the moment Emily’s voice appeared in the video, thin and terrified, and the world inside him went silent.

The next thing he remembered was Max pushing his head into John’s hand, trying to comfort him without understanding why the room felt like grief.

John went to the sheriff’s office with a folder.

He printed screenshots at the library, each page a piece of proof. He brought the vet report from Doc Stevens—infected cuts, stress-induced decline, accelerated progression of Max’s cancer markers that had already been a concern. He brought Emily’s statement, written in a child’s careful handwriting because she wanted to do it right.

Sheriff Brennan didn’t stand when John entered. The office smelled like leather, old coffee, and power that had been sitting too long without challenge.

“What can I do for you, John?” Brennan asked, voice too casual.

John placed the folder down. “I’m filing a report. Assault. Animal cruelty. Kidnapping attempt. Property destruction. All of it.”

Brennan flipped through with theatrical boredom, pausing at a screenshot where Cody’s face was clear as daylight, clippers in hand, grin wide. He lingered a second too long, as if memorizing the image—not with concern, but with calculation.

“I don’t see any evidence,” Brennan said.

John blinked once, slow. “There’s video. He posted it.”

“My son was home all day,” Brennan replied, smiling like he’d just made the weather change.

John’s voice stayed level, but it took effort. “That’s your son’s face. That’s your son’s voice.”

Brennan pushed the folder back. “Looks like an old dog that got a bad haircut.”

Emily stood stiff beside John, trying to be brave. John felt her trembling through the air, the way you feel heat off asphalt.

“I have witnesses,” John said.

“You have nothing,” Brennan said, standing now, stepping closer as if height could rewrite truth. “What you have is trouble. And trouble can get… complicated. For you and your girl.”

John picked up the folder.

He didn’t argue. He didn’t beg. He didn’t threaten. He had learned that men like Brennan fed on that. Instead, he nodded once.

“I’ll come back with a lawyer,” he said.

Brennan laughed, the sound following them out like a door slamming behind their backs. “Good luck finding one in this town.”

The lawyer refused. The pharmacist stopped meeting John’s eyes. The school called about Emily fighting after a boy told her her dog deserved what happened. The principal spoke in the flat voice of someone trained to keep peace by sacrificing the vulnerable.

Emily got three days suspension. The boy got one.

John took her hand and walked out, his jaw so tight it ached.

At home, Max lay on his bed, patched and bandaged where Doc Stevens had shaved clean around the cuts. The dog’s skin looked wrong without fur—exposed, too human, too fragile. Emily sat beside him and read aloud from a worn library book, voice shaking but determined, as if words could build a wall.

John sat at the kitchen table with bills spread like a battlefield map. Vet bill. Antibiotics. Rent due soon. Truck worthless with a dead transmission. He held the truck title in his hands, thumb tracing the edges. It felt like surrender.

Emily stood in the doorway in pajamas with faded unicorns.

“Why don’t we just leave?” she asked quietly. “Move somewhere else.”

John looked at her—the way she held herself too carefully, the way children do when they’ve learned early that life can break without warning. He wanted to say yes. He wanted to scoop her up and put her in a world where people didn’t laugh at suffering. But he also knew what leaving would teach her.

“Because running teaches you dignity is optional,” John said.

Emily’s eyes filled. “But nobody’s listening.”

John set the title down.

“Then I’ll make them listen,” he said, and his voice sounded like something older than anger. It sounded like a promise.

Saturday morning, he woke before dawn.

He found cardboard in the garage. A black marker with a cap that clicked like a trigger. His hand was steady, the way it used to be during briefing notes and map markings.

He wrote:

JUSTICE FOR MAX
K94721 — K9 VETERAN
ASSAULTED. IGNORED. FORGOTTEN.

Emily watched from the doorway, small in her oversized T-shirt.

“Dad,” she whispered, “what are you doing?”

“Telling the truth,” John said.

He slid a “For Sale” sign into the truck window even though the truck couldn’t move. Symbol mattered. Sacrifice mattered. Then he took the cardboard sign under his arm and stepped outside.

Max followed.

Slow, bandaged, fur patchy where the clippers had eaten it away, but head high.

They walked to the courthouse.

The town square was empty at seven in the morning, quiet except for pigeons and the faint hum of distant traffic. John chose the bottom step where the sign could be seen from the road. Max sat beside him like he’d been assigned a post.

John stood.

And the day began.

The first person passed at 7:30—a woman in running clothes who slowed, read the sign, looked at Max’s scarred skin, and swallowed hard. Her eyes watered. She nodded once at John like a prayer and kept going.

Most people didn’t stop.

Some looked away so hard it was almost violent.

John didn’t move.

His leg hurt. His shoulders burned. The sun rose higher and Texas heat wrapped around him. Max leaned against his shin, warm and steady. Emily sat on the steps with a book, reading but watching everything, learning what it looked like to hold ground.

By noon, seventeen people had passed.

Sixteen looked away.

One nod was enough to start.

Across the street, a black pickup idled. Cody sat behind the wheel, phone up, recording. He smirked as if he were documenting entertainment.

John held the sign higher.

Not for Cody. For the cameras he hoped would come later. For the truth that didn’t need permission.

Days stacked.

Day two. Day three. Day four.

The sign’s ink began to fade at the edges. John’s hands developed blisters from gripping cardboard in the sun. His leg dragged more often, fatigue turning pain into a constant companion. Max’s breathing sounded heavier. At night, John washed Max’s wounds and checked for swelling, for infection, for anything that would mean the end was closer.

Emily went to school and came back quieter each day, learning that cruelty spreads through whispers and side glances, learning that the hardest part wasn’t the men who laughed but the people who stayed silent.

On day eight, Dolores from Millie’s Diner crossed the street with a thermos and a paper bag. She moved like someone who had already decided that fear was not going to run her life.

“You look like you could use this,” she said, setting the thermos down.

Real coffee. Dark and rich. The smell alone was a kind of mercy.

The bag held a roast beef sandwich, chips, a pickle. John’s mouth watered before he could stop it.

“I can’t pay,” he said.

Dolores waved a hand. “Didn’t ask you to.”

She crouched, joints popping, and held out her hand to Max. Max sniffed, then leaned into the touch when she scratched behind his ear. Gentle. Practiced. Dolores knew dogs.

“My son was a Marine,” she said quietly. “Came back different. You got that same look.”

John didn’t trust his voice. He only nodded.

Dolores stood again, looking older for a moment, then stubborn.

“You need more,” she said. “You let me know.”

She walked back across the street like she hadn’t just done something brave.

John fed Max a piece of turkey tucked inside the sandwich. Max chewed carefully, mouth sore, but his tail thumped once against the concrete. Slow. Grateful.

The next day, Hal Patterson rolled up in a wheelchair. Vietnam veteran cap. Cigarettes. A Purple Heart pinned to his jacket like an old argument with fate.

He stared at the sign a long time.

“K9, huh?” he rasped. “Which unit?”

John kept it simple. “JSOC.”

Hal’s eyebrows rose. He studied John with a new kind of attention.

“You were…?” Hal started.

John didn’t confirm. Didn’t deny. Some things were not owed to strangers, even kind ones.

Hal lit a cigarette and exhaled smoke like punctuation.

“I know a guy,” he said. “Investigative reporter. Austin. Loves stories about vets getting screwed. Might listen.”

He handed John a business card: Marcus Webb.

John slipped it into his pocket like it weighed more than paper.

Day by day, the courthouse steps became a place where the town’s conscience could either show up or keep walking.

On day sixteen, Emily ran up after school with a bag full of handmade cards. Construction paper and glitter, crayon stick figures, words spelled wrong but feelings spelled perfectly: GET WELL MAX. YOU’RE A HERO. WE LOVE YOU.

She taped them to the wall behind John until the courthouse looked less like stone and more like a child’s insistence that goodness was real.

That night, a forty-pound bag of premium dog food appeared on their porch. No note. No name. John checked it for tampering out of habit, then poured a bowl for Max. The sound of kibble against metal felt like something sacred.

Three days later, Marcus Webb arrived with a camera and a reporter’s calm that hid sharpness underneath. He knelt first, not to John, but to Max.

“Can I hear what happened?” Webb asked, setting a recorder down.

John told him. From the start. Every detail. No embellishment. Just facts shaped by a voice trained to report.

Webb’s eyes caught on the tattoo as Max shifted. He leaned closer.

“K94721,” he read softly, then pulled out his phone.

Color drained from his face as he scrolled.

“John,” Webb said, voice suddenly careful, “do you know who this dog is?”

“He’s Max,” John replied.

Webb turned the phone so John could see an old archived article. A younger Max in tactical gear. A headline about an embassy bombing. A K9 who detected a secondary device and saved dozens of lives—including a senator who was now governor.

John stared until his vision blurred. He felt Emily’s hand slide into his.

The story went national in a week.

And then—finally—the system moved.

Not because the system was good.

But because it could no longer afford to pretend it hadn’t seen.

Texas Rangers arrived. Then federal agents. Cody and his friends were arrested. Evidence pulled from phones. Deleted videos recovered. The sheriff was placed on leave as corruption investigations opened like a cracked dam.

John should have felt triumph.

Instead, he felt time.

Because Max was deteriorating fast, the stress and injuries accelerating what Doc Stevens had already warned about. Treatment began—better medicine, better food, clinics in Austin, a specialist who spoke gently about immunotherapy and “buying quality time.”

Months were bought.

A year was stolen from the jaws of the inevitable.

Max’s fur grew back silver-gray, making him look dignified rather than broken. He still limped, still tired easily, but on good days he trotted a little, tail lifting like he remembered joy. Emily grew taller. John’s house felt less like a bunker and more like a home again. Coffee in the morning tasted less like regret.

Then spring came again, and with it the quiet signal that borrowed time was ending.

Scans showed progression. The specialist’s eyes softened the way doctors do when they’re delivering the end of hope, not cruelly, but honestly.

“Days,” she said. “Maybe a week.”

John didn’t argue. He had known. You can feel it when a body begins to let go.

That evening, he carried Max outside to the oak tree in the backyard, where bluebonnets bloomed like Texas insisting on beauty no matter what humans did. Emily lay down beside Max and wrapped her arms around his neck.

“I love you,” she whispered, voice shaking. “Forever and ever.”

Max’s tail moved. Barely, but it moved.

John sat on the other side, hand on Max’s ribcage, feeling each breath. They were slow now. Heavy. But still there.

“You did good, buddy,” John murmured, voice cracking. “You saved so many people. You saved me.”

Max’s cloudy eyes found him once, steady even at the edge of leaving, as if his entire life had been built on one message: I’m here. I’m with you.

The vet came quietly. No sirens. No ceremony. Just a needle that promised peace.

John asked for one minute. He pressed his forehead to Max’s. Emily’s tears soaked into fur that had finally grown back enough to feel like home again.

“Thank you for choosing me,” John whispered. “For staying when I was broken.”

Max sighed. Not fear. Not pain. Just a final exhale of contentment.

The injection went in.

Max’s breathing slowed.

Slower.

Then stillness.

John didn’t wail. He didn’t scream. Grief arrived like the ocean—silent at first, then all at once, too vast to fight. Emily cried into his shoulder. They stayed under the oak tree until the sun sank, until the bluebonnets turned dark in twilight, until the world felt real again.

A year later, a statue stood in the town square where John had held his sign.

Bronze. Life-sized. A German Shepherd seated at attention, alert and proud.

The plaque read:

MAX K94721
Hero. Protector. Friend.
He taught us dignity is not given. It is lived.

People came. The governor came. Texas Rangers came. Veterans came, quiet men with older eyes, the kind who knew what service cost. John stood with Emily—older now, straighter, carrying herself with a kind of calm that looked like Max.

When they handed John the microphone, he held it awkwardly, still not someone who liked attention.

“Max didn’t ask to be a hero,” he said. “He just loved his people and protected them.”

His voice carried across the square, steady.

“That’s all any of us can do,” John continued. “Love fiercely. Stand firm. And don’t give up.”

Afterward, Emily placed fresh bluebonnets at the statue’s feet and whispered something only she and Max would ever know.

Life continued, because life always does.

A young dog came later—two years old, rescued from a shelter, bright eyes and too much energy, tail wagging like the world had never hurt anyone. Emily named her Hope. John smiled the first real smile he’d had in years, the kind that reached his eyes.

On quiet mornings, John still drank coffee on the porch. Emily still read beside him. Hope still chased tennis balls in the yard. And inside, on the mantle, Max’s medal rested beside a photo of the three of them—John, Emily, and Max—captured in a moment before goodbye, when they were whole.

John would sometimes pick up that photo and trace Max’s face with his thumb.

“We’re okay, buddy,” he would whisper. “Just like you taught us.”

And maybe that was the truth that mattered most.

Not that the town finally listened. Not that the system finally moved. Not even that justice arrived, late and imperfect.

But that an old dog, scarred and tired and faithful to the end, had been loved completely.

That he had been seen.

That he had not been forgotten.

Because love does not end when breath does.

It echoes.

And in that echo, we find forever.

Related Posts

My sister looked down on me for being an HVAC technician and kicked me out of Thanksgiving, humiliating me in front of her lawyer friends by announcing, “She never even went to college.” Then her boss stood up and asked…

I’m Lena Turner, 32 years old. If someone told you that your own sister would kick you out of Thanksgiving dinner for being too blue-collar to meet her...

My dad said teaching wasn’t a real career. At his medical gala, he introduced me to 300 guests as “my daughter who teaches preschool—basically a babysitter.” Everyone laughed, until the Harper Foundation chair took the mic and said, “Interesting introduction, Dr. Brooks. Now let me tell everyone who your daughter really is. You may want to sit down.”

My name is Bethany Brooks and I’m 34 years old. The moment my father called me “just a babysitter” in front of 300 medical professionals, I knew it...

Running late and covered in grease after fixing a woman’s vintage car, I showed up to meet my girlfriend’s parents — then the woman I helped pulled in.

My girlfriend’s parents never hid the fact that they didn’t like me.They were polite about it, refined even, but disapproval has a tone. It lives in pauses, in...

She took his seat without knowing he was the Black CEO — his next words stopped her cold.

Flight 447: The Seat That Exposed Everything Flight 447 departed from Atlanta on what appeared to be an ordinary afternoon in 2025. At the gate, the familiar choreography...

A homeless boy risked everything to save a freezing girl by climbing a mansion wall — her billionaire dad witnessed the entire moment.

The coldest night of the year did not arrive quietly.It descended on Chicago like a verdict already passed. The wind tore through the city with something that felt...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *